[2008]DLCA6514 • February 21, 2008 • Court of Appeal
MICHAEL ATTA OSEI vs. CHRISTIAN MENSAH AFLAKPUI & ANOR.
The dispute arose from long-running litigation over the same parcel of land at West Achimota, Accra. The 1st respondent had, from 1988, pursued multiple actions against the appellant claiming title, possession and related reliefs over the land, while the appellant counterclaimed for declaration of title, recovery of possession, damages for trespass and perpetual injunction. In earlier proceedings, the appellant ultimately succeeded in the Circuit Court, Court of Appeal and Supreme Court, obtaining judgment over the whole disputed land, including possession and injunction. Despite those final decisions, the 1st respondent repeatedly initiated fresh proceedings and applications in the Circuit Court and High Court seeking to re-open the question of the extent of land covered by the earlier judgments, contending that the appellant was entitled only to 0.18 acres while he retained 0.25 acres and a building on the land. Relying partly on an obiter remark in a High Court ruling that what remained was a surveyor’s task, the respondents caused the Regional Surveyor and his agents to enter the land to demarcate it. The appellant then sued for damages and injunction. In the course of that suit, the respondents sought to commit the appellant for contempt on the basis that, while their application for interim injunction was pending, he entered the land and demolished the structure thereon. The High Court committed the appellant for contempt. He appealed.
read moreYAW APPAU, JA. The circumstances leading to this appeal as disclosed in the record of appeal are so phenomenal that there is the need to recount them in order to avoid any perceived ambiguities in the judgment of this Court. The 1st respondent in this appeal Christian Mensah Aflakpui embarked on two separate suits against the appellant Michael Atta Osei in the year 1988 in respect of a plot of land situate at West-Achimota in Accra. The identity of that plot of land, which was the same in all the suits, was not in issue in those suits. The appellant also counter claimed against the respondent for the same reliefs in all the suits. The reliefs were for declaration of title, recovery of possession, damages for trespass and perpetual injunction to that same piece of land. These two suits were all in the Circuit Court Accra, presided over by two different judges. One of them was before her Honour Judge I. N. N. Ashong (as she then was), now Justice I. N. N. Ashong Yakubu. The Suit No...