[2015]DLSC3042 • February 19, 2015 • Supreme Court

THE REPUBLIC vs. HIGH COURT, HUMAN RIGHT DIVISION EX-PARTE: NAA OTUA SWAYNE

The applicant, Naa Otua Swayne, was the complainant and first prosecution witness in a pending criminal trial at the Circuit Court, Accra, titled The Republic v Prince Kofi Amoabeng and John Aidoo, involving charges of fraud as to thing pledged or taken in execution and abetment. After the prosecution closed its case and a submission of no case was overruled, Prince Kofi Amoabeng opened his defence and testified. Before calling his witness, he applied to the High Court, Human Rights Division, for certiorari and prohibition to quash the Circuit Court proceedings on the basis that the continuation of the criminal trial infringed his fundamental human rights and that the evidence disclosed no criminal liability. The High Court accepted that contention, quashed the entire criminal proceedings, and prohibited the Circuit Court from continuing the trial. Naa Otua Swayne then invoked the Supreme Court’s supervisory jurisdiction to quash the High Court’s decision. Portion of judgment: 'The applicant herein, NAA OTUA SWAYNE, was at the time material to this case a complainant in a criminal case pending before His Honour Judge Francis Obiri sitting at the Circuit Court, Accra...' and 'Before he could call a witness, he invoked the supervisory jurisdiction of the Accra High Court Human Rights Division...'

read more

ANIN-YEBOAH JSC:- My Lords, On the 19th of February, we granted an application for certiorari and made far-reaching consequential orders but deferred our reasons. We now proceed to offer our reasons for granting the application. To appreciate the grounds leading to the grant of certiorari against the High Court, Accra [Human Rights Division], it is crucial to briefly state the facts of the case culminating in this application. The applicant herein, NAA OTUA SWAYNE, was at the time material to this case a complainant in a criminal case pending before His Honour Judge Francis Obiri sitting at the Circuit Court, Accra. The case was intituled as: CASE № D6/278/12: THE REPUBLIC V PRINCE KOFI AMOABENG AND JOHN AIDOO; and for a fuller record the charge sheet states thus: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT ACCRA STATEMENT OF OFFENCE FRAUD AS TO THING PLEDGED OR TAKEN IN EXECUTION contrary to section 143 of Act 29/60. PARTICULALRS OF OFFENCE PRINCE KOFI AMOABENG: BANKER; For that you.....